Home  >  

Good maps and bad maps...

Author photo
| | Comments (3)
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

As a developer, I've known for some time now that my design skills are not exactly "professional level". Let me be honest - I typically walk past my wife in the morning to ensure I dressed in something that isn't too horrible. But while I may not be able to design my way out of a paper bag - I think I recognize good design. A perfect example of this came up this week. My city (Lafayette, LA), will soon be offering fiber to the home, much sooner than our local cable and phone company. (And trust me, they put up quite a fight, but that's another story.) They recently rolled out a Flash based map to show what areas would first be getting fiber service. You can see the map here.

lusmapbig.png

Try to use that map. Go ahead. I'll wait. Even better - try to read the map. While the UI isn't too complex, the actual data - the maps - are near impossible to use. I've been in Lafayette for about 5 years, but after 10 minutes of trying to find my home, I simply gave up.

I made a comment to this effect on the Lafayette Pro Fiber Blog, a web site run by local supporters of the fiber initiative in our city. (As I said - it was a bit of a fight.) They were quickly able to employ Google's mapping service to make a much better result. Same data really - but the presentation is incredibly more easy to read. For me it probably just comes down to having additional zoom levels, but that one feature alone allowed me to find my street (unfortunately I'm not in the first roll out) in about 30 seconds!

So again - I don't pretend to be a great designer - but I think this a great set of examples on how one RIA can be much more usable than another.

Read more from Raymond Camden. Raymond Camden's Atom feed cfjedimaster on Twitter

Comments

3 Comments

Joseph said:

I was wondering how long it took them to build their zoom thingy. Using google API is way faster.

I think reinventing the wheel to replace an already open API that already excells isn't a great idea. Though, I'm not too sure; maybe next gen maps are Flash based (flex).

Anon said:

The second map (from google) doesn't describe the same thing the first one does. ?

You know what - their web site is down - and I bet the data was being served from there. I guess just give it a few hours and they should be back up.

Leave a comment


Tag Cloud

Question of the Week: Dream App

If you had an unlimited budget and unlimited resources what application would you build and why would you build it?

Answer

Latest Features

Recommended for You

@InsideRIA on Twitter

Archives

  • Or, visit our complete archive.  

About This Site

Welcome to the premiere community site for all things RIA sponsored by O'Reilly Media and Adobe Systems Incorporated.