Home >
Full disclosure: Rich Tretola works for Herff Jones and I work for EffectiveUI, but neither of us had any real involvement in this application.
Today Herff Jones announced the launch of a robust new RIA for creating and editing yearbooks online. The application is called eDesign, and it lets teachers and students collaborate in real time through a fully functional and very powerful layout and content creation tool. Herff Jones is one of the nation's leading yearbook printing and distribution companies and developed eDesign to give schools a better tool for creating yearbooks. eDesign was developed by Herff Jones in conjunction with a team of developers from EffectiveUI.
I took eDesign for a test drive recently and was really impressed by the sheer number of usable features the team was able to implement. Imagine Adobe InDesign done exclusively for yearbooks and you have a pretty good idea of how eDesign works. It features a fully functional layout tool with all of the tools you'd expect and implements "in place" editing with a smoothness most editors lack. It allows users to organize their content in ways required for the yearbook industry (pages, spreads, etc.) and gives them complete control over the way their content is displayed. It features a robust WYSIWYG editor that makes it easy to create new content and edit your existing pages.
When users log in, they're greeted with an intuitive dashboard showing the status of the content they're responsible for. They can send and receive messages related to respective spreads and see an intuitive horizontal thermometor indicating the state of the pages they've been assigned. Sticky notes and all other "To do" type messages applied to any element of the book appear in this dashboard, making it easy for users to keep track of what others have said without having to flip through every one of their assigned pages.


Probably the single most impressive feature is the way eDesign handles text. The application targets Flash 9, so it can't take advantage of the huge improvements in text handling that Flash 10 provides. It's obvious that a lot of time was spent specifically on text - as any good developer will tell you, managing dynamic text in Flash 9 is a difficult task. The result is an application that handles complex text arrangements without distorting the letters and dynamically loads a wide variety of fonts (around 350 come packaged with the application) without reducing performance.
eDesign also has some really great permissions features that show a high level of understanding of the complex use-cases around yearbooks. A number of different roles can be assigned to each user and allow book administrators to lock pages after they've been edited or prevent student editors from even knowing some pages exist.
It's a little strange to say, but I was also really impressed with the help page for this application. Most applications strive so hard to be usable that they don't bother with a help page. While usability is certainly important, no application with any significant level of complexity is going to make sense to everyone all of the time. It's nice that Herff Jones put in the time and effort to style and brand the help page. It feels like a usable tool rather than something they threw together at the end.
All in all, I'm very impressed with this application. It's one of the most complex RIA's I've seen yet, but it's also one of the most functional and complete. The only question I have about eDesign is wether there's a desktop version in the works - currently it's locked in my browser and subject to the performance and memory restrictions that entails. While the browser provides a level of ubiquity other delivery platforms don't, the growing penetration of Adobe AIR and use of the common Flex code-base make an AIR app seem like a logical next step. It seems like the performance would improve and the usability would also benefit from features like the ability to drag and drop content from the desktop directly onto the book.
For more information, check out the eDesign homepage or EffectiveUI's microsite.








Facebook Application Development
E-design is quite possibly the most terrible yearbook creation interface I have ever worked with.
@Courtney: have you worked with many others? Why do you think it's terrible?
I'm a middle school yearbook advisor that desperately needs an affordable, collaborative-friendly yearbook program. I'm strongly considering E-design, please be more specific in your struggles with the program.
I used eDesign this year; it has its positives and negatives.
Pros:
It's free.
Students can log in and work on the book anywhere, as long as they have an internet connection. (my favorite feature!)
It gives you control over student access to the book, and you can look at their pages as they work on them. You can also leave notes for them on the pages they're working on.
If a picture has been enlarged too much (becomes grainy/pixelated if printed), it will give you a warning.
You can submit your pages quickly online.
You proof the pages yourself so that cuts back on the time spent between you and the plant.
Cons:
If you're designing your own cover, you'll still need to use InDesign to create it; covers can't be created in eDesign (at least not this year).
You're limited in the fonts that you can use. You can't upload fonts (or not this year), so you have to choose from what they have available.
Some functions simply don't work/produce good looking results (like creating shapes from text so you can outline words and such), so you're limited to the effects you can create...or forced to be Extra creative.
A lot of the cons with this interface are that it lacks the power to do things that give books a more polished and professional look. You work a little harder to produce a "wow" factor. Also, I ended up doing a lot of design in Photoshop and uploading it into eDesign because it couldn't do what I wanted. Part of the limits of eDesign are probably related to what an internet browser can handle.
Hope this helps!
Well this is the second year I've been with my high school yearbook staff, and we've used Herff Jones both years. In my opinion, it's more about the way your yearbook is presented, then what creator you use. If your yearbook was terrible, all you have to blame is yourself. All eDesign did was help you.
My school is using eDesign for the second time. I just learnt a bit about it a few days ago. Can't wait to get started!